How to work with your genes, to maintain or restore your health
...a general guide to what is involved and the resources available to help
This article is just for those interested in genetic testing as related to health,
and need to know where to start.
There are a lot of recommendations here, generated by ChatGPT, including to particular people and organisations. I am in no way recommending any of them. You are responsible for your own research, financial and health decisions.
Before we start, note that genes do not dictate that you will get sick and with what. They determine instead, which health issues you are prone to if your lifestyle is unsuitable for your genetic makeup. Understanding your genes helps you make the best lifestyle choices for you.
Part 1 is information on types of DNA tests.
Parts 2 and 3 are low cost independent pathways for those using Ancestry or 23andMe DNA data. (This is what I am doing.)
Part 4 gives a variety of higher cost pathways for those who want to take genetics seriously and have the budget to pay for support. (This is what I would do if I could.)
Part 1 - Which is the best DNA test to use
The question: ‘There are various DNA tests being used for health analysis. Which tests have the broadest spectrum of results when it comes to decoding health issues?’
ChatGPT:
When it comes to DNA tests for health analysis, those with the broadest spectrum of results typically analyze a wide range of genetic markers and provide comprehensive insights into potential health risks, carrier status for inherited conditions, and traits related to diet and lifestyle. Here are some of the most comprehensive DNA tests available for health analysis:
1. Whole Genome Sequencing (WGS)
Overview: This test decodes the complete DNA sequence, covering all 3 billion base pairs in the genome.
Pros: Provides the most extensive genetic information, covering known genes as well as potential areas for future research.
Cons: High cost and the need for detailed interpretation by a specialist.
Best For: Individuals looking for the most in-depth analysis that includes rare and currently unknown genetic variations.
2. Whole Exome Sequencing (WES)
Overview: Analyzes the exome, which includes all the protein-coding regions of the genome (around 1-2% of the genome but containing approximately 85% of disease-related genetic variants).
Pros: Offers a more targeted approach than WGS at a lower cost while still covering a large number of medically relevant variants.
Cons: May miss regulatory or non-coding regions outside the exome that could also influence health.
Best For: People wanting a comprehensive analysis focused on known health-related genes.
3. SNP Genotyping (e.g., 23andMe, AncestryDNA)
Overview: Tests for specific single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) associated with various traits, disease risks, and health predispositions.
Pros: Affordable, quick, and user-friendly; offers insights into common genetic traits and health risks.
Cons: Limited in scope compared to WGS or WES and may not cover rare genetic variants.
Best For: General health insights, ancestry information, and understanding common trait markers.
4. Clinical Panels (e.g., Myriad Genetics, Invitae)
Overview: Panels focus on specific health areas, such as cancer risk (BRCA1/BRCA2), cardiovascular disease, or hereditary conditions.
Pros: High accuracy for specific conditions, often used in medical settings for targeted analysis.
Cons: Limited to the conditions included in the panel and more expensive than SNP genotyping.
Best For: Individuals with a family history of specific diseases or looking for targeted screening based on symptoms or risks.
5. Comprehensive Health Reports (e.g., Nebula Genomics, Dante Labs)
Overview: Combines elements of WGS or WES with personalized health reports that cover an array of health and wellness topics, including metabolism, nutrient needs, predispositions to diseases, and drug response (pharmacogenomics).
Pros: Offers detailed health and trait reports with regular updates as new research becomes available.
Cons: Requires interpretation, and the cost can be higher than basic SNP testing.
Best For: People wanting comprehensive health insights along with regular updates and interpretation.
Specialized Considerations
Pharmacogenomics Tests: Focus on how your genes affect your response to drugs; useful for personalized medicine.
Epigenetic Testing: Examines chemical modifications to DNA that affect gene expression, offering insights into lifestyle impact on health (less common and more experimental).
Factors to Consider
Budget: Whole genome sequencing is the most expensive, while SNP genotyping is generally more affordable.
Data Interpretation: More detailed tests like WGS and WES may require specialized genetic counseling.
Health Focus: If you're seeking specific answers (e.g., cancer risk, metabolic health, etc.), targeted panels might be more efficient.
In summary, whole genome sequencing (WGS) offers the broadest spectrum of results, covering nearly all possible genetic variations. However, whole exome sequencing (WES) provides a strong alternative for medical-focused insights. For general health and budget-friendly options, SNP genotyping tests like those from 23andMe or AncestryDNA are popular choices.
Part 2 - On-line tools for producing genomic panels
For those who have Ancestry or 23andMe data, this is what ChatGPT has to say about getting the data interpreted.
Question: If using SNP Genotyping such as 23andMe or AncestryDNA, which are the best on-line tools to produce genomic panels?
ChatGPT: If you have raw DNA data from SNP genotyping services such as 23andMe or AncestryDNA, there are several third-party tools and services that can help you produce comprehensive genomic panels for health insights, trait analysis, and more. Here are some of the best tools for analyzing and interpreting your genetic data:
1. Promethease
Overview: A well-known tool that generates a detailed report by comparing your SNPs to the SNPedia database, which contains information on the effects of genetic variations.
Pros: Inexpensive, provides extensive scientific references, and covers a wide range of health-related topics.
Cons: Reports can be very detailed and technical, making them challenging to understand for those unfamiliar with genetics.
Best For: People who want a comprehensive overview and are comfortable interpreting dense scientific data.
2. Genomelink
Overview: An online service that provides insights into traits, wellness, diet, and ancient ancestry based on your DNA data.
Pros: User-friendly interface, regularly updated with new traits and reports, and offers both free and premium options.
Cons: Premium insights require a subscription.
Best For: Users interested in a wide variety of non-medical traits and wellness reports.
3. Nutrahacker
Overview: Provides detailed reports on how genetic variants may affect nutritional needs and reactions to supplements.
Pros: Tailored nutritional advice and supplement recommendations based on your genetic profile.
Cons: Limited in scope if you are looking for information beyond nutrition and supplements.
Best For: Those who want personalized dietary and supplement guidance.
4. SelfDecode
Overview: A subscription-based platform that offers detailed reports on health, wellness, and genetic predispositions, with actionable lifestyle and supplement recommendations.
Pros: Comprehensive health insights with well-explained results and actionable suggestions; integrates AI for ongoing updates.
Cons: Subscription can be expensive for some users.
Best For: Users looking for an ongoing, comprehensive health management tool with a clear focus on actionable health insights.
5. Genetic Genie
Overview: A free tool that focuses on producing reports related to methylation and detox pathways.
Pros: Especially useful for those interested in methylation cycle analysis, including MTHFR and COMT variants.
Cons: Limited to specific pathways; lacks broader health or trait information.
Best For: Individuals with a focus on methylation, detoxification, or understanding how genetic variants impact these processes.
6. Codegen.eu
Overview: An open-source platform that generates a free report based on your genetic data.
Pros: Covers a variety of health, trait, and ancestry information; no cost to use.
Cons: Not as user-friendly or visually appealing as some paid options.
Best For: Users who want free access to a broad range of genetic insights without paying for premium tools.
7. FoundMyFitness Genetic Report Tool
Overview: Created by Dr. Rhonda Patrick, this tool generates a report focusing on genes related to nutrition, metabolism, and wellness.
Pros: Offers in-depth insights with an emphasis on actionable health and wellness information.
Cons: Limited in scope compared to more comprehensive genomic tools; focuses primarily on nutrition and wellness.
Best For: Users interested in science-based health insights with a focus on diet and lifestyle.
8. LiveWello
Overview: A versatile tool that allows you to upload your raw DNA data to generate reports on health risks, conditions, and wellness.
Pros: Highly customizable with access to various templates for different health conditions; user community contributes new templates regularly.
Cons: Reports can vary in quality depending on the template used; more suited to advanced users.
Best For: Individuals who want a flexible, customizable approach to genetic analysis.
How to Choose the Right Tool
Depth of Analysis: For those looking for broad, detailed reports, Promethease, SelfDecode, or LiveWello are great choices.
Ease of Use: If simplicity and ease of interpretation are priorities, Genomelink or SelfDecode might be more suitable.
Budget: Codegen.eu and Genetic Genie offer free options, while tools like Nutrahacker provide affordable niche reports.
Specific Focus: For methylation and detox pathways, Genetic Genie is ideal. For nutrition-based insights, Nutrahacker and FoundMyFitness excel.
Choosing the best tool depends on your specific interests (e.g., health, nutrition, traits) and your comfort with technical genetic data.
Part 3 - Supplementation to support various genetic variants
This is a tricky question because we are all different. It is only possible to ask at all because we are not talking about healing anything. Instead we are talking about supporting a gene variant to work as well as it can, which is relevant to everyone with that variant. Nonetheless our genetic makeup is so complex that it is entirely possible that support that is valid for one person is not valid for another, so take enormous care with easing into dietary changes and/or supplementation to support genes.
Question: If using SNP Genotyping such as 23andMe or AncestryDNA, and on-line interpreting tools, which are the best on-line tools to identify suitable diet or supplementation for particular panels?
ChatGPT: When using SNP genotyping data from services like 23andMe or AncestryDNA, there are several online interpretation tools designed to help identify personalized supplementation strategies based on genetic panels. Here are some of the best tools for this purpose:
1. Nutrahacker
Overview: Nutrahacker provides reports that recommend supplements based on your genetic data and alerts you to supplements that may be harmful.
Pros: Offers targeted supplement recommendations for genetic variants, highlighting both beneficial and potentially adverse supplement responses.
Cons: The free report is limited in detail; premium reports are more comprehensive but come at a cost.
Best For: People interested in straightforward, actionable supplement advice tailored to their genetic makeup.
2. SelfDecode
Overview: A comprehensive platform that offers detailed health reports with personalized supplement and lifestyle recommendations based on your genetic data.
Pros: Integrates AI to provide up-to-date health insights and suggestions, including a wide range of supplements for various health conditions and genetic markers.
Cons: Requires a subscription, which might be pricey for some users.
Best For: Users looking for ongoing, holistic health management and tailored supplement guidance.
3. Genetic Genie
Overview: Although primarily focused on methylation and detox pathway analysis, Genetic Genie can help guide supplementation decisions for specific genetic variants like MTHFR and COMT.
Pros: Free and straightforward; useful for understanding genetic variants that impact methylation, which informs supplementation (e.g., B vitamins).
Cons: Limited to methylation and detox pathways without broader health insights.
Best For: Individuals focusing on methylation and detoxification who need basic supplementation suggestions.
4. StrateGene®
Overview: A tool developed by Dr. Ben Lynch that provides insights into genes affecting methylation, neurotransmitter balance, and detoxification. It also offers supplement guidance based on these pathways.
Pros: Provides clear, targeted supplement and lifestyle recommendations based on pathways impacted by specific genetic variants.
Cons: Primarily useful for those with an interest in methylation and related health issues; requires the purchase of the StrateGene® report.
Best For: Those specifically looking at methylation and detox pathways and seeking expert recommendations for supplementation.
5. FoundMyFitness Genetic Report Tool
Overview: Created by Dr. Rhonda Patrick, this tool emphasizes nutrition and health optimization, providing personalized recommendations for diet and supplements based on your genetic data.
Pros: Science-based and detailed; great for users who want well-researched supplement advice to improve health and wellness.
Cons: Has a narrower scope focused on nutrition and lifestyle rather than comprehensive supplementation strategies.
Best For: Individuals seeking nutrient and supplement advice, especially in areas like vitamin D metabolism, Omega-3 response, and antioxidant support.
6. MTHFR Support
Overview: Focuses on analyzing genetic variants related to methylation, detoxification, and other metabolic pathways, with recommendations for targeted supplements.
Pros: Useful for those with MTHFR and related genetic variants, providing targeted supplement advice like methylated B vitamins.
Cons: Limited to specific pathways and requires some background knowledge for effective use.
Best For: People with methylation pathway concerns looking for tailored supplement suggestions.
7. LiveWello
Overview: Offers a platform where users can upload raw genetic data to generate reports, including supplement recommendations tailored to health risks and conditions.
Pros: Highly customizable with user-generated templates and reports that can include supplement guidance.
Cons: Reports vary in quality depending on the templates used; may require some expertise to navigate.
Best For: Advanced users who want the flexibility to explore different panels and receive tailored supplementation guidance.
How to Choose the Best Tool for Supplement Guidance
Depth of Supplement Analysis: Nutrahacker, SelfDecode, and StrateGene® offer deep insights and specific supplement recommendations based on your genetics.
Budget: Genetic Genie and Nutrahacker provide affordable or free basic supplement reports, while SelfDecode and StrateGene® have higher costs for more detailed insights.
Health Focus: If you're primarily concerned with methylation and detox pathways, StrateGene® and Genetic Genie are ideal. For broader health and wellness, SelfDecode and Nutrahacker are better suited.
Ease of Use: Nutrahacker and FoundMyFitness are user-friendly, while LiveWello requires more navigation and customization.
Tips for Using These Tools Effectively
Consult with a Professional: Consider reviewing the results with a healthcare provider or a genetic counselor to ensure that supplementation aligns with your overall health plan.
Stay Updated: Genetic research evolves rapidly, so using platforms that provide ongoing updates, such as SelfDecode, can be valuable.
Combine Insights: Using more than one tool can provide a fuller picture, particularly when looking for both general wellness recommendations and detailed pathway-specific supplements.
Part 4 - For those with good budgets who want support for this process
Question: For those able to pay whatever it takes, what are the best pathways to take involving experts. Who are the experts and what services do they provide?
ChatGPT: For those with the financial ability to pursue in-depth genetic analysis, personalized medicine, and holistic wellness plans, engaging with leading experts and services can provide unparalleled insights. Here are some of the best pathways and experts known for their comprehensive, cutting-edge approaches:
1. Functional Medicine Clinics and Physicians
Overview: Functional medicine specialists use a personalized, systems-based approach to healthcare. They often integrate genetic testing to optimize treatment plans.
Notable Experts:
Dr. Mark Hyman: A leader in functional medicine and founder of The UltraWellness Center. Offers personalized genetic analysis and tailored health protocols focusing on nutrition, lifestyle, and supplementation.
Dr. Ben Lynch: An expert on genetic pathways, particularly methylation. He provides in-depth analysis of genetic variants affecting health through his clinic and resources at StrateGene®.
Services Provided: Full genome analysis, functional lab testing, personalized supplementation, nutritional plans, and lifestyle modifications.
2. Genomics-Based Medical Institutes
Overview: These institutes focus on translating complex genetic data into personalized healthcare plans.
Notable Institutions:
Cleveland Clinic Center for Functional Medicine: Collaborates with experts in genomics to provide tailored health strategies based on comprehensive testing.
Mayo Clinic’s Center for Individualized Medicine: Provides personalized, genomics-based treatment and consultations for those with complex health issues.
Services Provided: Whole-genome sequencing, advanced health risk assessments, detailed consultations with genetic counselors, and personalized interventions.
3. Private Genomics and Biotech Companies
Overview: High-end genomic services offer comprehensive DNA sequencing and interpretation, often combined with expert consultations.
Notable Companies:
Human Longevity, Inc. (HLI): Founded by Dr. J. Craig Venter, HLI provides extensive whole-genome sequencing, deep phenotyping, and personalized health plans.
Invitae: Offers full-genome and exome sequencing services, including expert genetic counseling to guide health decisions.
Veritas Genetics: Specializes in whole-genome sequencing with expert interpretation and ongoing updates on relevant genetic insights.
Services Provided: Complete sequencing, consultations with genomics experts, continuous health monitoring, and disease risk reduction plans.
4. Integrative Health Centers
Overview: Centers offering integrative approaches often combine genomics, nutrigenomics, and advanced health data analysis.
Notable Experts:
Dr. Jeffrey Bland: Known as the father of functional medicine, his Personalized Lifestyle Medicine Institute (PLMI) connects clients with genomic analysis services and holistic health strategies.
Dr. Daniel Amen: Specializes in brain health and uses genomic data as part of his integrative treatment plans at the Amen Clinics.
Services Provided: DNA-based brain health assessments, customized supplement protocols, nutrigenomic evaluations, and tailored wellness plans.
5. Specialized Genetic Counseling and Nutrition Experts
Overview: These experts focus on translating genetic data into actionable health and nutrition strategies.
Notable Experts:
Dr. Rhonda Patrick: Researcher and health expert who provides insights into genomics-based dietary and lifestyle changes.
Dr. Kara Fitzgerald: Focuses on epigenetics and personalized health protocols, especially regarding the methylation cycle and its impact on aging and wellness.
Services Provided: Genetic data interpretation for diet, lifestyle modifications, tailored supplement protocols, and epigenetic guidance.
6. Executive Health Programs
Overview: Luxury programs designed for high-net-worth individuals looking for personalized health optimization.
Notable Services:
Mayo Clinic Executive Health Program: Offers comprehensive genetic testing as part of full medical evaluations and personalized care plans.
Cleveland Clinic Executive Health Program: Integrates advanced genetic and metabolic profiling for preventive health management.
Services Provided: Full medical and genomic evaluation, one-on-one consultations, continuous monitoring, and bespoke health solutions.
7. Pharmacogenomics Services
Overview: Personalized medicine based on how your genetics affect your response to drugs.
Notable Experts:
Genelex and Admera Health: Provide pharmacogenomic testing with expert analysis to tailor medications based on your genetic profile.
Services Provided: DNA testing to predict drug responses, consultations with pharmacogenomic specialists, and personalized medication plans.
What These Experts and Services Provide
Comprehensive Genetic Panels: Full-genome or targeted panel analysis for health conditions, methylation pathways, detoxification, and more.
Customized Supplementation and Diet Plans: Experts create tailored protocols based on your genetic makeup to support optimal health.
Epigenetic Guidance: Insights on lifestyle choices that can influence gene expression and promote longevity.
Preventive and Proactive Health Management: Identification of genetic risks and strategies to mitigate potential health issues.
Ongoing Support: Regular consultations and access to cutting-edge updates in genetic science to refine health strategies.
How to Choose the Right Pathway
Scope of Health Concerns: If you have specific health issues like methylation or neurological concerns, seek out experts like Dr. Ben Lynch or Dr. Daniel Amen. For broader health, institutes like HLI or Mayo Clinic provide holistic plans.
Budget: Consider the scale of services. Executive health programs and private genomic companies provide extensive packages, while consultations with functional medicine specialists can be more focused.
Desired Outcome: For longevity and wellness optimization, Human Longevity, Inc. and integrative health centers offer expansive resources, while pharmacogenomics services are essential for medication response management.
Consulting with these high-level experts and utilizing their services ensures access to the most advanced and personalized health strategies based on genetic data.
Can you help?
I intend to keep writing of my journey through this rather strange time in my life, and for this planet. As soon as I know what does and does not work to take back some level of control of our lives and our health, I will share that with you.
If you think my writings are worthwhile, you can help me get more subscriptions and donations by sharing this article on other social media platforms, and by re-stacking this article in Substack Notes.
Or make a PayPal donation here to help with ongoing medical costs. Every little bit helps. Donations are paying for tools and supplements that I could not otherwise afford, in my quest to see out my days with grace.
Oh wow, how did I miss this?!
I was just going to add this note in case it is helpfule to someone, about the oura ring:
From a friend:
I'm not sure if this is helpful for you at all but I highly recommend an oura ring for anyone with poor health. Before the ring I used to just guess and wing it with the kid. He looks happy so he must be doing good, right? Not true at all. These new oura updates are so amazing . I can now see the kids heart rate in 30 minute intervals all day and night. I see his stress level in 15 minute intervals. This is so valuable because I will now get a baseline on his regular supplements. That way if I change anything I can better see how it affects him. It shows so much more. His old ring that I am wearing isn't compatible. Thankfully his ring is new enough they upgraded him! So valuable to see all night sleep patterns, heart rate. It doesn't offer blood pressure readings unfortunately